Article 107(1) TFEU: The Four Cumulative Criteria of State Aid
Every State aid compliance review starts with the four cumulative conditions of Article 107(1) TFEU. If even one condition is absent, the national measure falls outside EU State aid control.
1. Transfer of State Resources & Imputability
State resources encompass central, regional, and municipal budgets, public development banks, and parafiscal levies controlled by public authorities. Crucially, the measure must also be imputable to the State under the Stardust Marine jurisprudence.
2. Economic Advantage & Market Economy Operator Principle (MEOP)
An advantage exists whenever a public intervention relieves an undertaking of charges normally borne by its budget. Where a public body invests, lends, or guarantees on terms a rational private investor would accept (MEOP), no State aid arises.
3. Selectivity (Material and Regional)
General tax or economic policy measures open equally to all undertakings are not State aid. Selectivity arises when benefits are restricted to specific sectors, company sizes, geographic zones, or discretionary administrative rulings.